Hum se Muhammad bin Bashar ne bayan kiya, kaha hum se Ibn Abi Adi ne bayan kiya, un se Shu'bah ne, (doosri sanad) kaha mujh se Bishr bin Khalid ne bayan kiya, kaha hum se Muhammad bin Ja'far ne, un se Shu'bah ne, un se Sulaiman ne, unhon ne Abu Wail se suna, woh Hudhaifah Radi Allahu Anhu se bayan karte thay ke Umar bin Khattab Radi Allahu Anhu ne poocha: Fitnah ke bare mein Rasoolullah Sallallahu Alaihi Wa Sallam ki hadeeth kis ko yaad hai? Hudhaifah Radi Allahu Anhu bole ke mujhe zyada yaad hai jis tarah Rasoolullah Sallallahu Alaihi Wa Sallam ne farmaya tha. Umar Radi Allahu Anhu ne kaha phir bayan karo (Ma'sha'Allah) tum to bahut jari ho. Unhon ne bayan kiya ke Rasoolullah Sallallahu Alaihi Wa Sallam ne farmaya: Insan ki ek aazmaish (fitnah) to us ke ghar, mal aur paros mein hota hai jis ka kaffara, namaz, roza, sadqa aur amr-bil-ma'roof aur nahi-anil-munkar jaisi nekiyan ban jati hain. Umar Radi Allahu Anhu ne kaha ke mein is ke mutalliq nahi poochta, balkay meri murad us fitnah se hai jo samandar ki tarah (thāthein maarta) hoga. Unhon ne kaha is fitnah ka Aap par koi asar nahi parega. Aap ke aur is fitnah ke darmiyan band darwaza hai. Umar Radi Allahu Anhu ne poocha woh darwaza khola jayega ya toda jayega. Unhon ne kaha ke nahi balkay tod diya jayega. Umar Radi Allahu Anhu ne is par farmaya ke phir to band na ho sakega. Hum ne Hudhaifah Radi Allahu Anhu se poocha, kya Umar Radi Allahu Anhu is darwaze ke mutalliq jante thay? Unhon ne farmaya ke isi tarah jante thay jaise din ke baad raat ke aane ko har shakhs janta hai. Mein ne aisi hadeeth bayan ki jo ghalat nahi thi. Humein Hudhaifah Radi Allahu Anhu se (darwaza ke mutalliq) poochte hue dar maloom hua. Is liye hum ne Masruq se kaha to unhon ne poocha ke woh darwaza kon hain? To unhon ne bataya ke woh khud Umar Radi Allahu Anhu hi hain.