Hum se Ishaq ne bayan kiya, kaha hum ko Yaqoob bin Ibrahim ne khabar di, kaha hum se hamare walid ne bayan kiya, in se Salih ne, in se Ibn Shihab ne, unhein Abu Idrees ne khabar di aur in se Abu Thalaba razi Allahu anhu ne bayan kiya ke Rasool Allahsalla Allahu alaihi wasallam ne paltu gadhe ka gosht khana haram qarar diya thu. Is riwayat ki mutabia-t Zubaydi aur Aqeel ne Ibn Shihab se ki hai. Malik, Mamar, Maajishoon, Yunus aur Ibn Ishaq ne Zuhri se bayan kiya ke Nabi kareem salla Allahu alaihi wasallam ne har phaarh kar khane wale darinde ka gosht khane se mana farmaya hai.