Hum se Ali bin Abdullah ne bayan kiya, kaha hum se Sufyan ne bayan kiya, in se Amr ne bayan kiya ke main ne Jabir bin Zayd razi Allahu anhuma se poochha ke logon ka khayal hai ke Rasool Allahsalla Allahu alaihi wasallam ne paltu gadhon ka gosht khane se mana kiya thu? Unhon ne kaha ke Hakam bin Amr Ghifari razi Allahu anhu ne hamain Basra mein yahi bataya thu lekin ilm ke samundar Ibn Abbas razi Allahu anhuma ne is se inkar kiya aur (istidlal mein) is aayat ki tilawat ki «qul-laa ajidu feema oohiya ilayya muharraman» .