Hum se Hasan bin Abdul Aziz ne byaan kiya , kaha hum se Abdullah bin Yahya ne , kaha hum se Haywah bin Shurayh ne , unhon ne Bakr bin Amr se , unhon ne Bukayr se , unhon ne Nafi se , unhon ne Abdullah bin Umar razi Allahu anhuma se ke ek shakhs (Habban ya Alaa bin Arar naami) ne poocha: Abu Abdur Rahman! Aap ne Quran ki yeh aayat nahi suni «wa in ta'ifatani minal momineena-qtatalu» ke ”jab Musalmanon ki do jama'atein larne lagein“ al-kh , is aayat ke bamujab tum (Ali aur Muawiyah razi Allahu anhuma donon se) kyun nahi larte jaise Allah ne farmaya «faqatilul-lati tabghi» . Unhon ne kaha mere bhatije! Agar main is aayat ki tawil kar ke Musalmanon se na laroon to yeh mujh ko achha maloom hota hai bah-nisbat is ke ke main is aayat «wa man yaqtul mominan mutammidan» ki tawil karoon . Woh shakhs kehne laga achha is aayat ko kya karo ge jis mein mazkoor hai «wa qatiloohum hatta la takoona fitnatun» ke ”un se laro taake fitna baqi na rahe aur saara deen Allah ka ho jaye .“ Abdullah bin Umar razi Allahu anhuma ne kaha (wah , wah) yeh larayi to hum Nabi Karim salla Allahu alaihi wasallam ke ahad mein kar chuke , is waqt Musalman bahut thore thay aur Musalman ko Islam ikhtiyar karne par takleef di jati . Qatl karte , qaid karte yahan tak ke Islam phail gaya . Musalman bahut ho gaye ab fitna jo is aayat mein mazkoor hai woh kahan raha . Jab is shakhs ne dekha ke Abdullah bin Umar razi Allahu anhuma kisi tarah larayi par is ke muwafiq nahi hote to kehne laga achha batlao Ali razi Allahu anhu aur Usman razi Allahu anhu ke baare mein tumhara kya itiqad hai ? Unhon ne kaha haan yeh kaho to suno , Ali aur Usman razi Allahu anhuma ke baare mein apna itiqad byaan karta hoon . Usman razi Allahu anhu ka jo qasoor tum byaan karte ho (ke woh Jang e Uhud mein bhaag niklay) to Allah ne un ka yeh qasoor maaf kar diya magar tum ko yeh maafi pasand nahi (jab to ab tak un par qasoor lagate jate ho) aur Ali razi Allahu anhu to (Subhan Allah) Nabi Karim salla Allahu alaihi wasallam ke chacha zaad bhai aur Aap damad bhi thay aur hath se isharah kar ke batlaya yeh un ka ghar hai jahan tum dekh rahe ho .