Hum se Ali bin Abdullah Madini ne byaan kiya . Kaha hum se Yahya bin Saeed ne byaan kiya Abdullah bin Abi Shaybah ki hadees ki tarah , lekin unhon ne apni is riwayat mein yeh izafa kiya ke Aisha razi Allahu anha ne kaha Nabi Karim salla Allahu alaihi wasallam ke marz mein hum Aap ke munh mein dawa dene lage to Aap ne isharah se dawa dene se mana kiya . Hum ne samjha ke mareez ko dawa peene se (baaz auqat) jo nagowari hoti hai yeh bhi isi ka nateeja hai (is liye hum ne israr kiya) to Aap salla Allahu alaihi wasallam ne farmaya ke ghar mein jitne aadmi hain sab ke munh mein mere samne dawa daali jaye . Sirf Abbas razi Allahu anhu is se alag hain ke woh tumhare saath is kaam mein shareek nahi thay . Is ki riwayat Ibn Abi al-Zinad ne bhi ki , un se Hisham ne , un se un ke walid ne aur un se Aisha razi Allahu anha ne Nabi Karim salla Allahu alaihi wasallam ke hawala se .