Hum se Muhammad bin Ar'arah ne byaan kiya , kaha hum se Shubah ne byaan kiya , un se Abu Bishr ne , un se Saeed bin Jubayr ne aur un se Ibn Abbas razi Allahu anhuma ne byaan kiya ke Umar razi Allahu anhu Aap ko (majalis mein) apne qareeb bithate thay . Is par Abdur Rahman bin Auf razi Allahu anhu ne aitraz kiya ke is jaise to hamare bache hain . Umar razi Allahu anhu ne farmaya ke main ne yeh tarz e amal jis wajah se ikhtiyar kiya , woh Aap ko maloom bhi hai ? Phir Umar razi Allahu anhu ne Ibn Abbas razi Allahu anhuma se is aayat (yani) «izha jaa'a nasrullahi wal fathu» ke mutalliq poocha . Ibn Abbas razi Allahu anhuma ne jawab diya ke yeh Rasool Allah salla Allahu alaihi wasallam ki wafat thi , Aap ko Allah Ta'ala ne (aayat mein) isi ki ittila di hai . Umar razi Allahu anhu ne farmaya ke jo tum ne bataya wahi main bhi is aayat ke mutalliq jaanta hoon .