Hum se Ahmad bin Yunus ne bayan kiya, kaha hum se Zuhayr bin Muawiyah ne, kaha hum se Mutarrif bin Tareef ne, in se Aamir Shabi ne bayan kiya. Abu Juhaifah se riwayat kar ke, kaha main ne Ali razi Allahu anhu se kaha. (Doosri sanad) Imam Bukhari rahmahullah ne kaha aur hamase Sadaqah bin Fadl ne, kaha hamain ko Sufyan bin Uyaynah ne khabar di, kaha hum se Mutarrif bin Tareef ne bayan kiya, kaha main ne Aamir Shabi se suna, woh bayan karte thay ke main ne Abu Juhaifah se suna, unhon ne kaha main ne Ali razi Allahu anhu se poochha kiya Aap ke paas aur bhi kuch aayitein ya suratein hain jo is Quran mein nahi hain (yani mashhoor mushaf mein) aur kabhi Sufyan bin Uyaynah ne yun kaha ke jo aam logon ke paas nahi hain. Ali razi Allahu anhu ne kaha qasam is Allah ki jis ne dana cheer kar ugaya aur jaan ko paida kiya hamare paas is Quran ke siwa aur kuch nahi hai. Albatta ek samajh hai jo Allah Ta'ala apni kitab ki jis ko chahta hai inayat farmata hai aur woh jo is varaq pe likha hua hai. Abu Juhaifah ne kaha is varaq pe kiya likha hai? Unhon ne kaha diyat aur qadi chhurane ke ahkaam aur yeh masla ke Musalman kafir ke badle qatl na kiya jaye.

Hum se Muhammed bin Salaam ne bayan kiya, unhein Wakee’ ne Sufyan se khabar di, unhon ne Mutarrif se suna, unhon ne Sha’bi Rahimahullah se, unhon ne Abu Juhaifah se, woh kehte hain ke main ne ’Ali Radhiallahu Anhu se poocha ke kya aap ke paas koi (aur bhi) kitaab hai? Unhon ne farmaaya ke nahi, magar Allah ki kitaab Quran hai ya phir feham hai jo woh ek musalmaan ko ata karta hai. Ya phir jo kuch is saheefe mein hai. Main ne poocha, is saheefe mein kya hai? Unhon ne farmaaya, diyat aur qaidiyon ki rihaayi ka bayan hai aur yeh hukm ke musalmaan, kaafir ke badle qatl na kiya jaaye.